Clinical Excellence Committee records

Planning for Change at Mount Sinai: Future Plan of Action and Summary of Recommendations of the C...

Identity elements

referentie code

US AA117.S003.SS002

Name and location of repository




Clinical Excellence Committee records


  • 1974-1977 (Vervaardig)


  • 2 boxes (7 inches)
  • electronic material

Naam van de archiefvormer

Institutionele geschiedenis

The Clinical Excellence Committee (CEC) was formally established in the Spring of 1974 by the Board of Trustees of The Mount Si¬nai Medical Center. The Committee was formed in response to a request from Dean [Thomas] Chalmers who, after reviewing the history and current problems of the clinical services at Mount Sinai, concluded that planning for change "must be based on data gath¬ered in an objective manner and presented for discussion and decision to the Board of Trustees." He proposed that a special committee of trustees be appointed and charged to study, review and recommend to the Board of Trustees optimum arrangements for organizing and evaluating the clinical services. He suggested that the committee function through three Task Forces composed of faculty and trustees: One to define goals and objectives of the academic center; another to analyze alternative patterns for financing academic appointments; the third to define methods for evaluation of competence of clinical staff in the areas of teaching, research and service responsibilities.

The Mount Sinai School of Medicine had evolved less than ten years ago out of The Mount Sinai Hospital of New York. These two institutions with their affiliated hospitals had developed into the Mount Sinai Academic Health Center. Evolutionary progress carried with it the responsibility to examine and act upon a variety of academic, financial and health-care delivery problems. Each set of problems emphasized the need to improve institutional performance by defining what we wish to achieve, how to achieve it and how to measure the quality of the achieve¬ment. The proposal for the CEC and its Task Forces was essen¬tially a mandate for strategic planning towards the long range objectives of the academic health center.

Objectives of this type had never been explicitly stated but examination of our past history, present operations and developing trends in clinical care, medical education and research made it apparent that our academic health cen¬ter was functioning as if its objectives are:

  1. Provision of health care services that are efficient, effective and comprehensive.
  2. Transmission and critical application of biomedical knowledge.
  3. Development and certification of individuals who will make significant contributions to the health needs of our society. j
  4. Conduct of high quality research in the life sciences.

The purpose of the Task Forces was to define goals and stra¬tegies that would assist in the attainment of these ob¬jectives. The Task Forces represented a vertical cross-section of the institution on the premise that planning for the future should involve those who will share responsibil¬ity for the effects of long-range planning. Thus, trustees, administrative officers, department chairpersons, senior and junior faculty of full-time and voluntary status, house officers, and students were involved in the process.

The Task Forces and a total membership of 159 participants were activated in September, 1974 and, through their sub¬committees, they pursued their charges and developed recom-mendations for the CEC during the following two years. Meet¬ings of the Task Forces and their subcommittees consumed 250 formally scheduled hours. The Clinical Excellence Com¬mittee met three times: at the beginning to review and app¬rove the planning process, at the halfway point to review progress of the Task Forces, and at the end to receive and approve the recommendations of the Task Forces.

Task Force A was charged to develop goals and objectives for the Mount Sinai Medical Center in recognition of its role as an academic health center by means of (1) analysis of the health care delivery system in the medical school and the hospital; (2) an investigation and analysis of the past and present issues and policies of Mount Sinai; (3) the development of alternative solutions and recommendations for the long-range future.

Task Force B was charged to develop an organizational model for the medical center and to consider the special problems of its faculty.

Task Force C was to propose methods of evaluation of future programs in medical practice, education and research.

Each Task Force created its own subcommittees that were charged to develop specific recommendations for review by the Task Force. Three inter-task force subcommittees were appointed to report recommendations on academic advancement, full time systems, and affiliated institutions to several of the Task Forces.

The Project Director [Paul J. Anderson, MD] and Project Coordinator [Carole Stapleton] served as staff for the Task Forces and their subcommittees, arrang¬ed and attended all meetings, prepared and distributed min¬utes of meetings, reviewed and distributed appropriate lit¬erature, and obtained and analyzed data on various subjects for use by the Task Forces and their subcommittees.

Recommendations developed by subcommittees were reviewed and modified by the appropriate Task Forces. Recommenda¬tions were then referred to the Dean, Steering Committee of the Academic Council and the Executive Faculty of the med¬ical school for approval or further modification. In some instances, recommendations were referred back to subcommit¬tee by the Task Force or back to the Task Force by the Ex¬ecutive Faculty for reconsideration. In all such cases, recommendations were modified and eventually accepted by the Executive Faculty. Although the option to do so was explicit, no minority reports were filed.

The recommendations were next presented to the Clinical Excellence Committee and, after acceptance at this level, were approved by the Board of Trustees of the Medical Cen¬ter, Inc. on October 18, 1976.

Content and structure elements

Bereik en inhoud

These files represent an almost complete official record of the Clinical Excellence Committee, the Task Forces, and their subcommittees. The minutes are complete, with only one exception. There are few interim reports or correspondence among the coordinators, the chairmen of the committees, and members. The final report is contained in Box 2, folder 1.

Some of the minutes have notes made by Dr. Thomas Chalmers, President and Dean of The Mount Sinai Medical Center and School of Medicine. The files probably came from that office, although, aside from these few notes, they are generic.


The files are arranged by Task Force and then alphabetically by subcommittee name.

Conditions of access and use elements

Voorwaarden voor raadpleging

This material is available for use. Contact the Archives ( for access to these materials.

Physical access

Technical access

Voorwaarden voor reproductie

Languages of the material

  • Engels

Scripts of the material

Taal en schrift aantekeningen


Generated finding aid

Acquisition and appraisal elements

Geschiedenis beheer

Directe bron van verwerving

Appraisal, destruction and scheduling information


Related materials elements

Bestaan en verblifplaats van originelen

Bestaan en verblijfplaats van kopieën

Related archival materials

Related descriptions

Notes element

Specialized notes

Alternative identifier(s)

Legacy ID from CMS


OCLC Number


Description control element

Regels of conventies

Sources used

Aantekeningen van de archivaris

Processed by Barbara Niss in November 1986.


Geografische trefwoorden

Genre access points

Voorwaarden voor raadpleging en gebruik

Related genres

Related places